This is an automated archive made by the Lemmit Bot.

The original was posted on /r/bestofredditorupdates by /u/LucyAriaRose on 2025-06-02 04:00:22+00:00.

I am still NOT the Original Poster. That is Gold_Wind_5888. She posted in r/AITAH

I made 2 BORU posts before this one- the first is here. Second is here. **New Update marked with *******

Thanks to u/Choice_Evidence1983 and r/BakingGiraffeBakes for letting me know about the new update!

Trigger Warning: racism

Mood Spoiler: OOP is doing great!

Original Post: October 19, 2024

Throwaway account

My boyfriend (28M) and I (22F) met at work two years ago. Technically I was working part-time during undergrad and he was a customer, but after a couple of months, we started going out. I really love this man and nothing has happened on this scale before, so I’m very confused about it.

My bf has a very tight group of friends. I am well acquainted with them, and their girlfriends. One of them Dave, just is married to Ellie (fake names). Ellie is an excellent cook and often hosts dinners, and everyone brings a dessert to those dinners. I am the youngest in the group, so most times they brush off my requests for contributing or bringing in a dessert. However, the last time I asked Dave and Ellie if they wanted anything extra like wine or some sweet dish for dinner, they said I could bring one of those sweet dishes I make for my boyfriend.

I’m Indian, and even though I can’t cook as well as my mom, and I’m well, in a different country for studies, I called my mom up and had her teach me properly how to make a specific Bengali sweet which is my favourite. I had my friends taste it and they said it was great. My boyfriend ate some and said it was excellent.

Except, last night, I greeted Ellie and kept the dish in the kitchen. When the food was brought out and my boyfriend told everyone I made it, I saw that someone had added cinnamon powder to the sweet. You never have the sweet with cinnamon powder. The dessert tasted like cinnamon and I felt horrible. Though everyone said thank you and it was good, I think my face gave it away, and my boyfriend took me aside and said that Ellie had told him that my sweet looked ‘too white’ and thought some cinnamon might bring some colour into it. I don’t know, I just felt awful and I started to tear up.

My boyfriend then defended Ellie and said that his friends already think I’m a child and not make a big deal of this and we will talk about it. I told him Ellie asked him first, couldn’t he have told her not to add cinnamon to the sweet?

He told me he didn’t think it was a big deal and asked me to drop the topic on the way home.

I didn’t text him goodnight and this morning he said he was sorry and said my crying made him feel like an awful person.

I don’t know, now I think I overreacted. AITA?

Some of OOP’s Comments:

To a now deleted comment:

Thank you. Btw, it was ‘Rosogolla’. I even had my mom ask our local sweet shop what quantity they used for the sizes of Rosogolla. I had managed the sweet to taste a lot like the sweet shop, so that’s why I was so upset. If it tasted bad I wouldn’t have cried.

Commenter: Actually you should’ve asked right at the table why is there cinnamon added to your dessert. Not in a shout/complain way to make a scene but to make it clear your dessert was spoiled and your contribution was pretty much sabotaged. Don’t cover other people f.ck ups. It’s on them, not you.

OOP: (downvoted) I didn’t want to embarrass Ellie or my bf. Plus I didn’t know who added the cinnamon during dinner, and I was too upset to even talk.

Commenter: So your boyfriend doesn’t defend you and apparently all his friends think you’re a child. Which he also doesn’t defend you against.

He’s also got 6 years on you, dudes nearing 30.

Does your boyfriend often treat you like a child? Does your boyfriend usually defend his friends when they do some fuck shit like this? Does your boyfriend defend you at ALL??

He should feel like an awful person. He is an awful boyfriend

OOP: I usually just hang around my boyfriend’s friends during these dinners. I admit I feel a little left out because they all have been friends for so long, and I’m from a different culture, but they have never said any outright offensive thing to me.

My boyfriend doesn’t treat me like a child. He mentioned before that due to my age his friends see me like a much younger sister…so I guess that’s why he said it.

I don’t know, I’m kind of rethinking his words.

Commenter: You should really your aunt have a round with your BF In Bengal, we don’t have GFs or housewives, we have queens of the house He needs to understand the bangali household hierarchy

OOP: There is no way am I going to tell this to my Maa. She already has reservations about my bf due to the age gap and the fact that he is not Bengali.

But thank you, your comment cracked me up!

A lighter comment:

I know!! I was horrified. And I had to EAT it and act like nothing happened, at the dinner table, to not cause a scene.

Traumatized by cinnamon rosogolla was not on my bingo card this year.

Top Comment:

VegetableBusiness897: Bf saying ‘everyone thinks you’re a child’, and him saying ‘we’ll talk about this later’ is him telling you he thinks you’re a child.

Gurl, tell him you’re tired of hanging out with judgemental old farts and you’re going to go find people younger and cooler to be with.

Please don’t think this guy hung the moon

Mini Update (Same Post)

UPDATE: Ellie saw this post. My boyfriend texted me to see if it was me. I said yes.

He said we needed to talk.

For safety purposes, my best friend will be here.

I don’t know, I never expected my post to blow up

[editor’s note- the post had 21K upvotes so did indeed blow up]

Update Post: October 21, 2024 (2 days later)

He said he needed space from the relationship.

I think with the way this post blew up and what happened because of a POST, I should clear up some things.

I never asked if I should leave my boyfriend for this. I asked if this was an overreaction; my crying. But having thousands of people tell me this was racially charged, Ellie wanted power, my bf is shitty, etc, my brain went haywire.

Bf called yesterday and when I got there (his house) with my best friend, Dave and Ellie were there. Ellie was crying and Dave looked really pissed at me. My bf told me to sit down and Dave started with how could I make a post that most of the people in the dinner party would recognise and know, and could shame Ellie and my bf. My bf was silent, and wouldn’t even look at me, and was only shaking his head.

It felt like I was a kid, being scolded by my parents with my elder sibling disappointed in my actions. That is what I felt and it looked. I admit, it was very spineless of me, but Dave went on for like a minute and I was just looking at my bf waiting for him to defend me. I asked Ellie, why would she alter my dish, after telling me to bring an Indian dish?

She said she thought Indian food would be brown. This woman has more Indian friends than me, and she thinks Indian food is brown. She grew up in the UK, FFs. And I felt so defeated. The comments, my friends, and people around me telling me his friends came first to him, not me. He said he didn’t think the sweet was a big deal. I told him I would never let my friend alter something he spent three days learning, getting people to taste it and got his mom involved in. He saw I put a lot of effort into it, so why let her alter it? Why couldn’t he ask me?

Ellie started to cry and say that she wasn’t being racist and she wouldn’t know that I put effort into it and now she couldn’t host dinners again. I said I used fake names, so why does it matter, unless she and Dave went around telling people? Bf told me he didn’t expect this from me. My best friend piped up that he expected that my bf would have a ‘f-ing’ spine, so I guess they were both disappointed.

My (ig now EX) Bf told me, in front of Dave and Ellie that he needs some space. I told him to get lost. I dunno what my best friend said to him after that, considering I left bf’s flat. I kind of tripped in the metro station, so now I’m crying on my best friend’s couch with an ice pack while his bf keeps giving me peach schnapps and my relationship has toppled over.

I wouldn’t have stormed out, had he looked at me once. He just looked 100 percent on Dave and Ellie’s side, and acted like I was the one with the problem when she caused me hurt. If his friends come first when they cause me hurt, where would I have been, if I decided to marry this man?

My friends are good to me and are acting like I’m some fragile glass. I even heard my best friend and his brother whispering loudly from the kitchen and his elder brother wanting to threaten him via Insta D…

Content cut off. Read original on https://old.reddit.com/r/BestofRedditorUpdates/comments/1l18hy7/final_update_aitah_for_crying_when_my_boyfriend/