San Francisco’s police and fire departments have urged the CPUC to oppose the expansion – they say they’ve tallied 55 incidents where self-driving cars have got in the way of rescue operations in just the last six months. The incidents include running through yellow emergency tape, blocking firehouse driveways and refusing to move for first responders.
I’d be curious to see how that compared to the number of idiot human drivers who got in the way and otherwise reacted incorrectly to emergency vehicles.
Big difference is that a human can be yelled at and told what to do, and we currently don’t have a good way for someone to do that with an autonomous vehicle.
As far as I’m aware, all autonomous vehicles have manual controls that can override them. The person inside the vehicle would have to take over when an emergency responder started yelling directions.
Some of the vehicles don’t have anyone in them.
https://missionlocal.org/2023/05/waymo-cruise-fire-department-police-san-francisco/
One of the incidents in question.
Well, you can just ram them out of the way with your firetruck. Obviously that’s not a great option either, but if the FD does that then any damages are on the robot-taxi company.
Sure, I suppose. Or just don’t expand the system until there’s some measure of system in place to keep the AI cars from fucking around in emergency situations.
Don’t some autonomous vehicles have an emergency responder mode, too?
Just have them be overridden with a key like Elevators. Let policemen and other responders be able to drive, stop or direct them by inserting the fireman’s key.
Or alternatively, just take full liberty and bash the autonomous vehicle out of the way. No key required.
Hell yeah and then we can get a universal remote from the dank web and have free cars literally everywhere I’m down.
It doesn’t necessarily have to be a get-free-car feature. It could be limited to 20km/h or something if operated in control mode.
We already have the tech to let signal lights at intersections know emergency vehicles are approaching so they can direct traffic accordingly. No reason this couldn’t be adopted to autonomous vehicles.
deleted by creator
Let policemen and other responders be able to drive, stop or direct them by inserting the fireman’s key.
Then they can be remote-controlled by criminals to abduct people. That doesn’t seem wise.
Stupid idea that’s clearly motivated by the city’s deference to their tech gentry. Self driving anything has too many questions and issues still. I’m also not inclined to table “well what about the problems with people driving?” That only tells me we need transit, not robo taxis.
Ding ding ding! We have a safe mode of robot transit: trains. See, we know exactly where they will go because they run on rails. Literally.
Trains aren’t safe. They just expose you to different dangers, like airborne diseases, pickpocketing, and stabbing.
I promise I’m not trying to make fun of you but this sounds a bit like a suburban person’s perception of the city rather than what the city is actually like. None of this is more common on a subway than anywhere else.
