Are there commonly used words or phrases that rankle you, or that have multiple ‘right’ usages, but you feel only one is actually correct?
I’ll go first, I have 3 big ones:
First, the plural of ‘roof’ is ‘rooves’. Hoof::hooves, calf::calves, half::halves, etc. Rooves, goddammit.
Second, you can’t eat your cake and have it, too. Conversely, you must have your cake in order to eat it. Thus ‘can’t have your cake and eat it too’ is nonsensical. No, I am not the Unabomber.
Third:



You can’t use “literally” to mean “figuratively”. The whole point of the word “literally” is to mean “NOT figuratively”. If you let “literally” mean “figuratively”, then the word “literally” literally doesn’t mean anything any more.
Semantic drift takes another victim.
My gripe is people who say “you cant use literally to mean figuratively” because the word is never used to mean figuratively!
You cant swap the words out and have the sentence mean the same thing!
“This literally makes my blood boil” does not equal “this figuratively makes my blood boil” BUT it does equal “this really makes my blood boil”
“Really” is another example of using a word that means “to be real or genuine” as a way to add intensity to a sentence. Its origin is from the word “real”.
The word “very” also fits this category since its from the late 13th century word verrei which means “true, real, entitled to the name, genuine”.
Very true
What do you think “figuratively” means? It means as a figure of speech. If your blood is not elevated to a temperature which causes it to begin to vaporize, it is not literally boiling. “Makes my blood boil” is a figure of speech to illustrate an emotion.
Yeah, that’s the problem. A word has a meaning, specifically to distinguish that the events described actually happened and are not colorful hyperbole, and those words are reduced to uselessness.
The more we keep eroding the real meanings of words, the more relentless the treadmill becomes. Precise terms become loosened slang becomes generic fluff. How do I convey to a person that something which happens in a common figure of speech actually happened in real life?
That is the function of “literally”, to describe an occurrence which aligns with a figure of speech to declare that no, this is not a figurative description, the events are described in accordance with the textbook definitions of the words used. And, like its predecessors, it doesn’t mean anything at all anymore except mild emotional intensification.
I know what the word means and thats why I picked that specific example. The word figuratively doesn’t swap out 1:1 here. It changes the meaning of the sentence despite being technically correct.
Saying “that figuratively makes my blood boil” changes the meaning of the sentence to be more about the figure of speech part while “that literally makes my blood boil” is adding emphasis to the mood the figure is trying to convey. These two sentence have different purposes and mean different things.
Meanwhile, again, “that really makes my blood boil” is functionally exactly the same.
When someone says “literally” in this context they arent saying “figuratively” they’re saying “really”, which is an entirely different word.
I think you misunderstand. If you’re not speaking literally, you’re speaking figuratively. I’m not saying that “literally” is used as a synonym for “figuratively”, I’m saying that it is used as a generic intensifier which does not specify that the statement is non-figurative.
The “literally” in “that literally makes my blood boil” is a generic intensifier, but the statement is figurative. The word specifically coined to unambiguously distinguish literal statements that resemble figurative statements no longer fulfills that purpose.
Yes I get what you’re saying. My point being that nobody is using “literally” to mean the word “figuratively”. They are using “literally” when speaking figuratively… which isnt the same thing. If they were using one word to mean another then they would be swappable without changing the meaning of the sentence.
I have no problem with people saying they are annoyed that people use “literally” when speaking figuratively since, as you pointing out, we have other intensifier words that mean the same thing.
My issue is that people specifically state that they are annoyed that people are using the word “literally” to mean “figuratively” when nobody is doing that.
Oh Lord, this one figuratively boils my piss.
And literally makes me barely mildly upset though I agree completely.
There are a few of these in English, they’re called contronyms as in, a word that also means it’s opposite. Like dust (to dust with something or to remove dust) or cleave (to separate or to smush together).
Why exactly we have these I couldn’t tell you, but they’re common enough there’s a word for it.
I think we’re past letting this happen. Literally has been used in this way for a quarter of a millenium or more.
But it robs the word of all utility. It’s a useless filler word. It’s the adverb that means nothing. And it forces people to look for other ways to clarify when they actually mean literally
Yeah I used to die on this hill too but language changes and literally being used in non literal senses is basically set in stone at this point. Future etymologists will probably have fun deciphering that lol
The entire purpose of language is to convey ideas based on a common understanding. When people start to use words to mean something completely the opposite of what they literally mean, or literally without any meaning at all, it ceases to become language at all . At this point it’s just a filler word. Which is unfortunate because I find myself not knowing what to use in it’s place when I literally mean literally.
You can still use literally. It’s pretty obvious in the cases where its actually literal vs where its used as a hyperbole.
But in regards to your convey ideas point: common misunderstands can absolutely result in language change. Language isn’t bound by rules or committees (much to the anger of Québec). Half the words we’re using right now have completely different meanings to what their origins referred to. I really recommend reading the wikipedia etymology pages for common terms because its very common for the definitions to get flipped or skewed
Edit: an easy example would be the word man which used to be a completely gender neutral term.
I’m literally shouting in disagreement right now
It’s very often not obvious. That’s precisely why it’s so shitty that it’s misused so often.
Uhhhhh yeah? It is? Ever taken an English class? Read a dictionary? These are the rules.
Which is completely fine as long as everyone speaking and hearing them today have a common understanding of what they mean. A huge number of conflicts are often cause by people who have a misunderstanding of words. Many times intentionally so.
Oh good point, I wonder what the Cambridge dictionary says
https://dictionary.cambridge.org/dictionary/english/literally
Touché. Sometimes the dictionary is wrong, too.
But this literally isn’t true.
Hmm, you make a compelling argument…
Hate to be pedantic but, you mean “its place” not “it’s place”. “It’s” means it is. “Its” means belonging to it.
Well I suppose if there’s a place to be pedantic about language, it’s here.
They did it themselves in their own argument for it.
They didn’t though.
But if you treat it literally in that sentence, then the sentence becomes a logical paradox. “If you let ‘literally’ mean ‘figuratively’” contradicts with “‘literally’ literally doesn’t mean anything any more”. No, it literally means figuratively, in that case. Hence, they are using it figuratively for dramatic effect to make their case.
No, it literally means literally. The first part was a hypothetical.
It does not, and has not, for a long time. But yes, this may be the single most abusive use of the English language that exists.
The etymology is more defensible, but my favorite is
I mean insofar as it’s a word that I hear people misuse a hundred times/day.
It’s hyperbole.
Literally this
This